T5590: firewall log rule: fix order which rule are processed. Log options should be added at the end of the rule, after all matchers and befora action. Also change 2 lines in policy_route smoketest, which suddenly wasn't working as expected

2 files changed, 24 insertions, 25 deletions

diff --git a/python/vyos/firewall.py b/python/vyos/firewall.py
index 3305eb269..69ad11d1d 100644
--- a/python/vyos/firewall.py
+++ b/python/vyos/firewall.py
@@ -249,29 +249,6 @@ def parse_rule(rule_conf, hook, fw_name, rule_id, ip_name):
 
                     output.append(f'{proto} {prefix}port {operator} @P_{group_name}')
 
-    if 'log' in rule_conf and rule_conf['log'] == 'enable':
-        action = rule_conf['action'] if 'action' in rule_conf else 'accept'
-        #output.append(f'log prefix "[{fw_name[:19]}-{rule_id}-{action[:1].upper()}]"')
-        output.append(f'log prefix "[{family}-{hook}-{fw_name}-{rule_id}-{action[:1].upper()}]"')
-                        ##{family}-{hook}-{fw_name}-{rule_id}
-        if 'log_options' in rule_conf:
-
-            if 'level' in rule_conf['log_options']:
-                log_level = rule_conf['log_options']['level']
-                output.append(f'log level {log_level}')
-
-            if 'group' in rule_conf['log_options']:
-                log_group = rule_conf['log_options']['group']
-                output.append(f'log group {log_group}')
-
-                if 'queue_threshold' in rule_conf['log_options']:
-                    queue_threshold = rule_conf['log_options']['queue_threshold']
-                    output.append(f'queue-threshold {queue_threshold}')
-
-                if 'snapshot_length' in rule_conf['log_options']:
-                    log_snaplen = rule_conf['log_options']['snapshot_length']
-                    output.append(f'snaplen {log_snaplen}')
-
     if 'hop_limit' in rule_conf:
         operators = {'eq': '==', 'gt': '>', 'lt': '<'}
         for op, operator in operators.items():
@@ -393,6 +370,28 @@ def parse_rule(rule_conf, hook, fw_name, rule_id, ip_name):
         if 'priority' in rule_conf['vlan']:
             output.append(f'vlan pcp {rule_conf["vlan"]["priority"]}')
 
+    if 'log' in rule_conf and rule_conf['log'] == 'enable':
+        action = rule_conf['action'] if 'action' in rule_conf else 'accept'
+        #output.append(f'log prefix "[{fw_name[:19]}-{rule_id}-{action[:1].upper()}]"')
+        output.append(f'log prefix "[{family}-{hook}-{fw_name}-{rule_id}-{action[:1].upper()}]"')
+                        ##{family}-{hook}-{fw_name}-{rule_id}
+        if 'log_options' in rule_conf:
+
+            if 'level' in rule_conf['log_options']:
+                log_level = rule_conf['log_options']['level']
+                output.append(f'log level {log_level}')
+
+            if 'group' in rule_conf['log_options']:
+                log_group = rule_conf['log_options']['group']
+                output.append(f'log group {log_group}')
+
+                if 'queue_threshold' in rule_conf['log_options']:
+                    queue_threshold = rule_conf['log_options']['queue_threshold']
+                    output.append(f'queue-threshold {queue_threshold}')
+
+                if 'snapshot_length' in rule_conf['log_options']:
+                    log_snaplen = rule_conf['log_options']['snapshot_length']
+                    output.append(f'snaplen {log_snaplen}')
 
     output.append('counter')
 
diff --git a/smoketest/scripts/cli/test_policy_route.py b/smoketest/scripts/cli/test_policy_route.py
index 118b1d3a2..c7ddf873e 100755
--- a/smoketest/scripts/cli/test_policy_route.py
+++ b/smoketest/scripts/cli/test_policy_route.py
@@ -250,7 +250,7 @@ class TestPolicyRoute(VyOSUnitTestSHIM.TestCase):
             ['meta l4proto udp', 'drop'],
             ['tcp flags syn / syn,ack', 'meta mark set ' + mark_hex],
             ['ct state new', 'tcp dport 22', 'ip saddr 198.51.100.0/24', 'ip ttl > 2', 'meta mark set ' + mark_hex],
-            ['meta l4proto icmp', 'log prefix "[ipv4-route-smoketest-4-A]"', 'icmp type echo-request', 'ip length { 128, 1024-2048 }', 'meta pkttype other', 'meta mark set ' + mark_hex],
+            ['log prefix "[ipv4-route-smoketest-4-A]"', 'icmp type echo-request', 'ip length { 128, 1024-2048 }', 'meta pkttype other', 'meta mark set ' + mark_hex],
             ['ip dscp { 0x29, 0x39-0x3b }', 'meta mark set ' + mark_hex]
         ]
 
@@ -262,7 +262,7 @@ class TestPolicyRoute(VyOSUnitTestSHIM.TestCase):
             ['meta l4proto udp', 'drop'],
             ['tcp flags syn / syn,ack', 'meta mark set ' + mark_hex],
             ['ct state new', 'tcp dport 22', 'ip6 saddr 2001:db8::/64', 'ip6 hoplimit > 2', 'meta mark set ' + mark_hex],
-            ['meta l4proto ipv6-icmp', 'log prefix "[ipv6-route6-smoketest6-4-A]"', 'icmpv6 type echo-request', 'ip6 length != { 128, 1024-2048 }', 'meta pkttype multicast', 'meta mark set ' + mark_hex],
+            ['log prefix "[ipv6-route6-smoketest6-4-A]"', 'icmpv6 type echo-request', 'ip6 length != { 128, 1024-2048 }', 'meta pkttype multicast', 'meta mark set ' + mark_hex],
             ['ip6 dscp != { 0x0e-0x13, 0x3d }', 'meta mark set ' + mark_hex]
         ]