The roadwarrior carol proposes 3DES_CBC encryption with HMAC_SHA1 authentication as the only cipher suite for both the ISAKMP and IPsec SA. The gateway moon defines ike=aes128-sha1 only, but will accept any other support algorithm proposed by the peer, leading to a successful negotiation of Phase 1. Because for Phase 2 moon enforces esp=aes128-sha1! by using the strict flag '!', the ISAKMP SA will fail.